What Your Favorite Pizza Topping Says About You
Let’s face it: pizza isn’t just food—it’s a personality test on a plate. Whether you’re a spicy adventurer or a lover of the classics, your go-to topping says a lot about who you are. Here’s a fun (and very scientific) breakdown of what your favorite pizza topping reveals about your personality.
Hot Honey
You’re bold, adventurous, and not afraid of a little spice in your life. Sweet and fiery? That’s basically your brand. Whether it’s skydiving, salsa dancing, or just ordering the wildest thing on the menu, you’re always down for something new. You’re the person everyone calls when they want to shake things up—and you never disappoint. If this sounds like you, try our Hiker Hot Honey ‘Za at Old Yale
Mushrooms
You’re grounded, thoughtful, and maybe just a touch mysterious. Like mushrooms, you thrive in cozy, earthy vibes (hello, rainy days and good books). You have a quiet confidence that draws people in, and you know the best way to enjoy life is with good company, great conversation, and a perfectly balanced pizza. You sound like a Fun Guy, so you should probably order the Fun Guy pizza at Old Yale!
Pineapple
You’re a rebel with a sweet tooth. Controversial? Maybe. Fun and unapologetically you? Absolutely. Whether people love or hate your topping of choice, you don’t care—you’re here for the flavor fusion and tropical vibes. You’re the life of the party and the first to suggest karaoke or a spontaneous road trip. The Old Yale pizza for you is our Pineapple Peak!
BBQ Chicken
You’re the epitome of “laid-back cool.” You love a good BBQ, cherish chill weekends with friends, and know how to balance indulgence with just the right amount of effort. BBQ Chicken lovers are all about comfort and flavor—you’re the friend who can make anyone feel at home, whether it’s with food, conversation, or a killer playlist. Next time you’re at Old Yale, you gotta give our Backyard BBQ Chicken a go!
Plain Ol’ Cheese
You’re classic, dependable, and proud of it. Why mess with perfection? You’re not here for fads or overcomplication—you know what you like, and you stick to it. Whether it’s your wardrobe, your Spotify playlist, or your pizza, your style is timeless, and you wouldn’t have it any other way. Alright Kevin McAllister, the Old Yale pizza for you is our Margherita… or our Little Explorer’s Cheese Pizzza…
Meat Lover’s Style
You’re bold, unapologetic, and all about going all-in. More is always better in your book—whether it’s toppings, adventure, or living life to the fullest. You’re the kind of person who turns a casual hangout into an epic night and never says no to an extra slice (or two). People know they can count on you for energy, excitement, and probably a hilarious story or two. At OYB, we’ve crafted the Sausage Fest pizza for all you meat lovers out there.
No matter what topping you’re into, there’s no wrong way to love pizza—just like there’s no wrong way to enjoy life (especially when pizza’s involved). Stop by and order your personality in pizza form. Your perfect slice is waiting!